It’s been an interesting
time to be working on Capitol Hill. As I’m writing this on Wednesday night, the
government has just reopened after being shut down for two weeks and three days,
on the evening before the government would have defaulted on its debt if it
hadn’t come to this agreement. With House and Senate offices operating with
skeleton staff, Congress people and Senators have had to hash out some kind of
deal which would allow them to pass a budget and fund, not just the government
itself, but all federal programs, from NASA to the Department of Veterans
Affairs to the National Parks.
For the past two weeks and
three days “non-essential” federal workers haven’t been in work, and both they
and the essential workers who have still had to come in haven’t been paid. They
will all be receiving back pay now that the government has reopened, but those
with government contracts will not, while the many businesses that rely on
federal workers will never get the revenue they’ve lost back and small
businesses that have been unable to get government loans will struggle to
recover. The shutdown has cost the economy around $24 billion.
So what was this all for?
Well, from the Republicans
perspective, nothing. They’ve not managed to delay Obamacare, they certainly
haven’t managed to get rid of it, the debt ceiling has been raised and
meanwhile they’re poll ratings have plummeted. Not that the Democrats have got
anything good out of this situation either – they have managed to defend
Obamacare and they haven’t had to give up anything up in exchange – but nobody
wants to see their time in government wasted while they’re caught in the first
government shutdown since 1996.
It’d be easy, as a Democrat,
to blindly blame the Republican Party for holding the workings of the federal
government hostage over a healthcare law that has already been passed. But
while this was an awful thing to do, I don’t blame the Republican Party. During
this shutdown, I’ve actually grown to respect a lot of Republican
representatives – from John McCain, who has consistently said that the GOP
should not have picked this fight the way they did, to Mitch McConnell, the
minority leader of the Senate who helped to work out the bipartisan bill that
went through the Senate (which over half the Senate Republicans voted for), to the
87 sensible Republicans in the House who voted with the Democrats for the bill
to reopen the government. The Senate women’s caucus, featuring representatives
from both parties, including Republicans Susan Collins from Maine and Lisa
Murkowski from Alaska, as well as many brilliant Democrats like Barbara
Mikulski of Maryland and Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, were instrumental in
getting the bill through the Senate.
To blame the whole of the
Republican Party is completely missing the point. The Tea Party and people like
its recent darling, Senator Ted Cruz, are the ones who made this whole debate,
which should have been about the budget, about Obamacare and who were willing
to take the government into shutdown over it. Ted Cruz, earlier today, called
the actions of such Republicans a “courageous act”, a view which I’m sure would
go down well with people who’ve been laid off because small businesses with government
contracts couldn’t afford to keep them on during the shutdown.
And then there’s Speaker
Boehner, the chair of the House, who has, until now, refused to put a vote on the
floor of the House. The Democrats have repeatedly said that if he put a bill
forward, the votes would be there to pass it; today, finally, they were proved
right. So why wouldn’t Boehner call of vote? Well, one theory says he was
worried that he’d lose his speakership, because Tea Partiers would oust him.
It wasn’t the whole
Republican Party that has been holding the government hostage for the past two
weeks and three days. It was an extreme right wing faction and those it is
pulling to the right with it.
So what does this mean for
the future? Well, this deal has not ended the debate. What was passed was only
a continuing resolution – which basically means government funding was
approved, but isn’t a proper budget. This means we still have to reach a more
long term agreement, or face another situation like the one in just in in a few
months.
And with the Republicans
being dragged further and further to the right, it’s going to be hard to come
to a long term agreement.
It’s easy as a Democrat to
rejoice at an increasingly unelectable Republican Party. But what might be
making it easier to win elections is making it harder and harder to govern. The
whole US system is based on reaching compromises, but when you have an
extremist Republican faction which won’t compromise, which won’t accept that it
can’t just have whatever it wants despite losing the Presidential and Senate
elections, which won’t, frankly, act like adults, coming to such compromises is
difficult, to say the least.
So while this may be making
it easier for Democrats to be elected, what’s the point of being elected if
you’re subsequent ability to govern is so stifled?
Trying to restore some
sense to the Republican Party is a task that lies primarily with the
increasingly exasperated moderates in that party, but there is one factor in
this that is worth us all considering. Gerrymandering – the redrawing of
congressional boundaries to create seats which will always vote for one party
of another – is a large factor in this GOP swing to the right. There are now
many seats where Republicans will always be elected, so instead of worrying
about the electorate, they worry about the Primary, where the registered
Republicans who will be voting are inevitably to the right of the mainstream.
This is dragging the whole party to the right. Fixing the problem of
gerrymandering is a problem for all parties.
I have to give a quick
shout out to the absolutely fantastic Democrats in the House and in the Senate
who have all worked so hard to end the shutdown. And here’s hoping we can
really move forward from here and really start finding long term solutions to America’s
problems (the President has said his first priority, starting tomorrow morning,
is immigration reform which is exciting). But with the Tea Party still here,
still powerful and still scarily detached from reality, getting things done in
Washington DC is still going to be very difficult for a the foreseeable
future.